SSRScientific and Social Research2661-43322981-9946Bio-Byword Scientific Publishing Pty. Ltd.10.26689/ssr.v8i7.15791ArticleThe Analysis of Differences between Pygmalion and My Fair Ladyhttps://artdesignp.com/journal/SSR/8/7/10.26689/ssr.v8i7.15791TangJiayao2026872026-08-14George Bernard Shaw’s play Pygmalion and the musical-film adaptation My Fair Lady share a highly similar narrative framework, yet differ profoundly in narrative logic, aesthetic effects, and thematic implications. Drawing upon adaptation theory and the perspective of intertextuality, this paper conducts a comparative analysis from three dimensions: narrative medium, audio-visual rhetoric and characterization, revealing the fundamental shifts of the two art forms between intellectual debate and sensory immersion, as well as social critique and romantic myth. The analysis shows that the film’s apparent fidelity to Shaw’s text is merely superficial; its genre conventions, especially the Hollywood musical’s preference for closure and emotional gratification, systematically dilute Shaw’s satire on class hypocrisy and patriarchal oppression, while softening Eliza’s final rejection of Higgins into an ambiguous, potentially reconciliatory finale. The study thus contends that adaptation is never a neutral transfer but a culturally embedded reinterpretation, and this finding provides a critical reference for evaluating screen adaptations of classic literature, particularly in terms of how medium-specific constraints and ideological contexts reshape narrative meaning.

Zhang S, 2019, An Analysis of the Mythological Framework in George Bernard Shaw’s Play Pygmalion. Theory Horizon, 2019(10): 102–108.

Hutcheon L, 2012, A Theory of Adaptation. Taylor and Francis, Oxfordshire.

An Y, 2020, Realism as Method and Beyond: Reading Notes on Bazin’s What Is Cinema? Contemporary Cinema, 2020(2): 113–119.

Kong Q, 2025, An Intertextual Study of Film and Literary Adaptation. Movie Literature, 2025(14): 73–77.

Long D, 2016, Spatial Narrative is Essentially A Transmedia Narrative. Hebei Academic Journal, 36(6): 86–92.

Wang Q, 2025, A Study on the Localization of Three Shakespearean Plays from the Perspective of Linda Hutcheon’s Adaptation Theory, thesis, Northeast Forestry University.

Qian C, 2000, Identity Concept and Identity Consciousness. Journal of Shenzhen University (Humanities & Social Sciences), 2000(2): 89–94.

Wu J, 2023, A New Interpretation of Pygmalion: The Influence of Parent-child Conflict and Electra Complex on the Ending of the Play. Appreciation of Famous Literary Works, 2023(3): 36–39.

Li E, Ouyang J, 2018, What Transformation? The Progressive Evolution from Image to Imagery in Pygmalion and My Fair Lady. Journal of Beijing Film Academy, 2018(5): 71–76.

Zhang R, 2019, From “Self” to “Double Self”: An Analysis of the Transformation of Eliza’s Female Character in Pygmalion. Daguan (Forum), 2019(11): 230–231.